Project Willow
Lesson: Competing For FoodMaterials
- 17 food station place cards
- 85 food cards (5 per place card)
- 15 encounter cards
- approximately 1,400 tally beads (divided equally between stations)
- 14 gathering mark popsicle sticks (7 per acorn and pinenut station)
- 17 baskets (from activity 4 - to hold tally beads/gathering marks at
stations)
- optional: "Dixie" cups to hold each student's tally beads
- optional: sheets of easel poster paper - teacher provided
Objectives:
- Students will gain insights to the Washoe hunting and gathering culture.
- Students will try to survive through the seasons by competing for food
with other "beings".
- Students will learn of the interrelationships of the natural world.
Background:
The world of the hunter/gatherer might first appear to be filled with
easy opportunities for resources, but competition within the Tribe and between neighboring
Tribes placed limits on the availability of these natural resources. The ancient Washoe
also had to compete with the native animals for food. The climate and natural disasters
such as fire and avalanches also helped to define the availability of the resources.
This lesson helps students better understand how and when resources were
available to the ancient Washoe. Students will participate in a simulated hunting and
gathering experience that attempts to simulate several natural events.
Before You Begin This Lesson:
- This activity is better suited for mature fourth graders. You may need to
modify the activity based on the character of your class. The activity can be modified by
reducing the number of survival points needed to survive each season, having one good
reader in each foraging group, reminding Washoe and bear not to spend too much time on
hunting and encounter conflicts, and by closely monitoring food cards and tally points.
- Take time to read through this entire lesson before you attempt to teach
it.
- Arrange your classroom to provide as much space as possible. You may even
try to run the activity in the multi-purpose room.
- Set up food stations with tally bead/gathering mark baskets on desks or
tables. Stations should have plant groupings that reflect actual plant communities.
- For example:
Riparian = Beehives, Elderberry, Cottonwood, Cattail, and Willow
Transition zones = Currants, Gooseberry and Sunflower
Pinon/Juniper woodland = Pinon and Brodiaea
Forest = White Fir and Deer Brush
Meadow = Wild Onion and Blue Camas
Sandy Desert = Indian Rice Grass and Grasshoppers
California = White Oak (Acorn) - .
NOTE: White Oak (Acorn) is found some distance from the Washoe home
range. This station should therefore be located farthest from other stations.
Activity:
- Open the activity by explaining that each student will play the role of
one of four organisms in search of food. The four organisms, or beings, students will role
play are:
Washoe, Bear, Deer, Pinyon, Jay
- Explain that there are specific rules these four beings will follow while
hunting/gathering for food. There are rules for both movement and hunting/gathering.
- Go over the following rules with your class:
I. Rules for Movement
- Student "beings" will visit up to four stations per 1 minute
feeding period.
- Student "beings" can chose to visit stations within or across
community groups.
- Student "beings" may return to a previously visited station
only after they have visited two other stations.
- Student "beings" must move as directed by the encounter cards.
(The encounter cards are long, black, laminated rectangles. Read a few excerpts from these
cards to give students a feel for how they are to move during portions of the simulation.)
II. Rules for Hunting/Gathering
A. Student "beings" will hunt/gather as follows:
- Bears - are solitary. They will hunt/ gather alone.
- Washoe - will hunt/gather in groups of two and three
- Mule Deer - will gather in two herds of four
- Pinyon Jay - will hunt/gather in three equal sized flocks
B. Student "beings" will hunt according to the following
schedule: (You may wish to record this feeding schedule on the front board)
Bear - Early morning, early evening, and night,
Washoe - Early morning, late morning, late afternoon,
and early evening
Mule Deer - Early morning and early evening
Pinyon Jay - Early morning, late morning, afternoon,
late afternoon, and early evening.
C. Student "beings" will have all individuals drawing food
cards.
D. No more than four food cards may be turned over by the students
during each feeding period.
E. Students will take the number of tally beads specified by the food
card.
F. Point value for foods are as follows: (You may want to record this
information onto the front board)
Primary food - 4 points
Secondary food - 2 points
Tertiary food - 1 point
Hunted food - 4 points
III. Hunting practices are as follows:
- Bears and Washoe may hunt Mule Deer.
- A Mule Deer may be hunted when it approaches within two feeding stations
of any
- Bear or Washoe.
- The hunter must use two hands to "tag" the deer.
- Tagging is only done when the deer are between feeding stations.
- Deer may escape the hunter by going to a different community station than
that of the original sighting station (a different colored station).
- When a deer is caught, it must give the hunter four beads and return the
- others to the station nearest where it was caught.
- If the deer does not have enough beads to supply the hunter, the hunter
may take the beads from the station nearest where the deer was caught.
- Student beings who have met their demise on a food card or through
hunting caN become the time keeper or station monitors who direct traffic and/or settle
conflicts for the remainder of that season.
- Students who have not survived should return their tally beads to the
nearest station.
- Encourage students to use critical thinking skills when deciding which
foods will be available during the four different seasons.
- Once you think the class has a general feel for the simulation, assign
students into the beings according to the following guidelines for a typical class size:
Bears - 3 students
Washoe - 7 students
Mule Deer - 8 students
Pinyon Jay - balance of class
- Encourage students to adopt the movements and mannerisms of the
"being" they represent. Arm bands of masking tape can be used to signify the
"being" they represent. You may decide to have students switch identities for
each season. It's up to you.
- There is a laminated encounter card for each of the 4 "beings."
These cards explain how each "being" is to react when they encounter another
"being". Because the bears hunt alone, each bear gets his or her own encounter
card. A leader from each of the remaining groups should be given an encounter card for
their group to share. These cards are held by the groups throughout the simulation. Make
sure each group understands how they are to react to other "beings" based on the
encounter cards.
- Once all roles have been assigned, begin the simulation by announcing the
season (begin with spring and move through the seasons in order) followed by the feeding
time (early morning - late morning - afternoon - late afternoon - early evening - night).
Important!
- Bears will not forage in winter because they are inactive.
- Washoe should only forage at winter if they do not have enough survival
points at the start of winter.
- Allow the students to circulate freely amongst the stations. If students
are "caught" between stations at the end of feeding times or seasons they must
return back to the group area and wait for their next feeding time to be announced.
- At the end of each season, have students count their tally beads.
Students will need a sheet of paper to record this information. If you decided to run the
simulation where students switch identities for each season, students that were Washoe
during the spring should switch their points with the new summer Washoe. Counted tally
beads should be recorded by the students for each being they represented and each season.
- The activity should proceed until the last feeding time of the last
season (ie. early evening of winter).
Closure:
- Instruct students return to their seats or gather in a large circle.
- Lead students in a discussion of the effects of competing for food (ie.
include: competition within and between species, availability of food sources, and random
events such as encountering a competitor or predator, climatic events, and opportunistic
activities).
- (Optional) Have students create seasonal graphs for: survival rates
within and between species, and tally points for each being they represented.
Evaluation:
- Students who are foraging at the wrong times may have not paid attention
to the introduction.
- Students reading skills can be informally evaluated by observing how many
food cards they draw and the points tallied.
- Watch for student understanding of the concept of "competition"
as it pertains to the hunting and gathering of food.
- The correct representation of graphs might demonstrate mathematical
comprehension.
|